The background of Godfrey Nims of Deerfield, Massachusetts, common ancestor of those with the name of Nims, is shrouded in mystery. New evidence was found, in 2019, to support that he was of English birth, though perhaps with French ancestry. No documentary evidence has been found to verify that he was a Huguenot, came to America as a lad, at first spelled his name Godefroi de Nismes, but changed the spelling to suit the colonial pronunciation.

Regardless of his birthplace, the first official record of Godfrey Nims appears on September 24, 1667, in a Springfield, Massachusetts court record.

"James Bennet, Godfrey Nims & Benoni Stebbins, young lads of Northampton being by Northampton Commissionrs bound ouer to this Corte to answer for diverse crimes & misdemeanrs comitted by them, were brought to this Corte by ye Constable of yt Towne wch 3 lads are accused by Robert Bartlett for that they gott into his house two Sabbath dayes when all the family were at the Publike Meeting: On ye first of wch tymes, they vizt. 24 shillings in silver & 7s in Wampum with the intention to run away to the ffrench: Al which is by them confessed, wch wickedness of theires hath also been accompanyd with frequent lying to excuse & justify themselves especially on Nims his pt, who it seemes hath been a ringleader in their vilainys: ffor all wch their crimes and misdemeanors this Corte doth Judge yt the said 3 lads shalbe well whipt on their naked bodys vizt, Nims & Bennet with 15 lashes apeece & Bononi Stebbins with 11 lashes. And the said Nims & Stebbins are to pay Robert Bartlett the summe of 4L being counted treble according to law for what goods he hath lost by their meanes. "

Archival records of Massachusetts list Godfrey Nims as one of many from Northampton who signed a petition in 1668 requesting relief from taxation on goods brought into the colony's ports. He also appears with others when taking the Oath of Fidelity to the government on March 25, 1672/3, at the County Court at Northampton. Again, family tradition tells us that Godfrey soon came to Deerfield, Massachusetts around 1670, perhaps as early as the third settler. A deed dated 1679 gives the first written indication that Godfrey settled at Deerfield, where he later shared in the holding of public offices, including constable, tax collector, selectman, and later, as a member of the school committee. The present White Church, town office, town hall, and Memorial Hall all stand on land formerly owned by Godfrey. J. R. Trumbull's History of Northampton, Massachusetts describes Godfrey as "the owner of considerable property and...an honored and respected citizen."

In 1677, Godfrey married Mary Miller Williams, widow of Zebediah Williams who had been killed earlier by Indians. Following the death of Mary in 1688, Godfrey married Mehitable Smead Hull in 1692, widow of Jeremiah Hull. He had six children with Mary and five with Mehitable, in addition to caring for two stepchildren each that the widows brought to the marriages. As the records demonstrate, Godfrey Nims joined the Puritan society in the Connecticut Valley, learned to make his living as a cordwainer (shoemaker) as well as a farmer, and raised a large family. Like other settlers, he shared the work and faced tragedies and dangers common to the area. The greatest blow came on February 29, 1704, when about 2 hours before day "ye French & Indian enemy made an attaque upon Derefield, entering ye Fort with Little discovery though it is sd ye watch shot of a gun & cryed Arm, weth verry few heard."

The attackers burned most buildings and killed or took captive most of the settlers. Godfrey died within a year, and it is from the four surviving children, John, Ebenezer, Thankful and Abigail, that members of the Nims family are descended.

Below is a portion of The Story of Godfrey Nims translated to French by Lise Rochette-Menard. 

L’histoire de Godfrey Nims

Les antécédents de Godfrey Nims de Deerfield, Massachusetts, ancêtre commun de la famille Nims, sont entourés de mystère. Une des hypothéses soutient qu’il était un Huguenot venu en Amérique alors qu’il était encore un tout jeune homme. Initialement, il aurait orthographié son nom godefroi de Nîmes, mais il en changea l’orthographe plus tard pour tenir compte de la pronunciation faite de son nom dans la Nouvelle-Angleterre coloniale. Une autre hypothése soutient qu’il était naissance anglaise, mais peut-être avec une ascendance française. Aucune preve documentaire n’a été trouvée pour identifier son pays d’origine, malgré les nombreux efforts déployés au cours de ans.

Quel que soit son lieu de naissance, la première fois, mention officielle de Godfrey Nims apparaît le 24 septembre 1667, dans les archives de la Cour à Springfield Massachusetts.

“James Bennet, Godfrey Nims et Benoni Stebbins, jeunes hommes de Northampton, sont sommés par les Commiossioners (commissaires) de Northampton de paraître devant cette cour pour répondre de divers crimes et délits commis par eux, rapportés à cette cour par le constatlett lors de deux jours du sabbat alors que toute la famille assistait à l’assemblée publique dominicale. La première fois, ils ont volé 24 shillings en argent et 7 rangées de Wampum, avec I’intention de s’enfuir chez les Français. Ils ont tout avoué, et ce, utilisant de fréquents mensonges pour s’excuser et se justifier, surtout Nims. Il semble que Nims était le chef de file durant leurs méfaits. Pour tous leurs crimes et délits, le juge de cette Cour condamne les 3 jeunes à être fouettés directement sur la peau, Nums et Bennet de 16 coups de fouet et Benoni Stebbins de 11 coups de fouet. Et les dits Stebbins et Nims devront payer à Robert Bartlett la somme de 4 L, tel que conformément à la Loi, pour les biens qu’il a perdu á cause de leurs méfaits.”

A Summary of the Godfrey Nims Family

Spouse #1, Mary Miller Williams

Children:

1. Mary Williams, b. December 24, 1673. Godfrey's stepdaughter later married Nathanial Brooks in 1695 at Deerfield. Nathanial, Mary, and two young children were all captured in the 1704 raid. Nathanial later was redeemed; the fate of the two children is unknown. Mary Williams Brooks, on the 8th day of the forced march, relayed that she had been "disabled by a fall on the ice, causing a miscarriage during the night. I will not be able to travel far, and I know they will kill me today." Speaking with her minister, also one of the captives, she asked, "Pray for me that God would take me to himself." They parted and she went calmly to certain death, March 7, 1704.

2. Zebediah Williams, b. 1675; captured by Indians with stepbrother John Nims on October 8, 1703. Died a captive in Canada on April 12, 1706.

3. Rebecca Nims, b. August 12, 1678; died August 30, 1678.

4. John Nims, b. August 14, 1679; captured by Indians October 8, 1703, and escaped from Canada in 1705. Married his step-sister Elizabeth Hull on December 19, 1707. He died December 29, 1762.

5. Rebecca Nims, b. August 14, 1679, a twin of John. Married Philip Mattoon January 15, 1702/3. She was killed in the 1704 raid on Deerfield, age 24. Philip was captured and died on the forced march to Canada.

6. Henry Nims, b. April 29, 1682; killed in 1704 at Deerfield, age 22.

7. Thankful Nims, b. August 29, 1684; married Benjamin Munn January 15, 1702/3; d. July 11, 1746.

8. Ebenezer Nims, b. March 14, 1686/7; captured and taken to Canada in the 1704 raid; redeemed in 1714; returned to Deerfield with fellow captive and wife Sarah Hoyt.

Spouse # 2, Mehitable Smead Hull

Children:

1. Elizabeth Hull, b. December 23, 1688; married step-brother John Nims as noted above; d. September 21, 1754.

2. Jeremiah Hull, b. January 15, 1690; burned to death in the house of his father Nims, when that home was destroyed by fire, January 4, 1693/4.

3. Thomas Nims, b. November 6, 1693; d. at the age of three, September 10, 1697.

4. Mehitable Nims, b. May 16, 1696; killed in 1704 at Deerfield, age 7.

5. Mary Nims, b. February 28, 1698/9; killed in 1704 at Deerfield, age 5.

6. Mercy Nims, b. February 28, 1698/9; a twin of Mary, also killed in 1704 at Deerfield, age 5.

7. Abigail Nims, b. May 27, 1700; captured in the 1704 raid at Deerfield, and taken to Canada as captive. She remained in Canada the rest of her life, marrying fellow captive Josiah Rising, (Ignace Raizenne)

Note the toll of Godfrey's family members killed or taken captive in the 1704 raid on Deerfield: His second wife captured, dying on the forced march to Canada. One son killed, and one captured, to be redeemed ten years later; four daughters killed that day; one daughter captured and taken to Canada, never to return. A step-daughter, Mary Williams Brooks, and a son-in-law, Phillip Mattoon, captured and killed on the march; a grandchild, infant Mattoon, killed in the attack. Earlier in 1703, a son and stepson captured and taken to Canada, where one escaped and the other died captive. One might well imagine the burden of these tragedies contributing to Godfrey's death sometime early in 1705. 

JOHN NIMS (8 SURVIVING LINES)
Elizabeth       
Mehitable
John, Jr.
Thomas
Elizabeth
Jeremiah
Mary
Daniel
  

THANKFUL NIMS MUNN (9 SURVIVING LINES)
John
Thankful
Mary
Benjamin
Abigail
Samuel
Rebecca
Sara
Mercy